ProspeKtive

Transitional third places (TLT): SSE organizations for another "to come"!

June 2024

Expert

Pascal Glemain

Pascal Glemain

Ph-D and Lecturer in Management of Social Economy Organizations

Université Rennes 2, UMR6590-CNRS, ESO-Rennes

In the first half of 2024, two symposiums on Third-Places took place in quick succession. The first was held at Grenoble Alpes University on March 14, 2024. It addressed the question: "Productive third places, revealing a new local economic model?". The second took place at Sciences Po Rennes from April 02 to 04, 2024. It focused on "Third places and solidarity policies: opportunities and weaknesses of new spaces for social action". Synthesizing the two, the result is that we are in the presence of "new spaces for social action (...) revealing a new local economic model". Where there is "novelty", the possible translation is that of "rupture", "profound change" or "bifurcation" relative to a previous state. The concept of "transition" towards another societal model on a territorial scale therefore seems to be the obvious one. But is it really appropriate to speak of "transitional third places" (TLT)?

Third places for societal transition: what are they?

New, more responsible consumer behaviors, new ways of working (telecommuting), a new relationship with work (the job you have, rather than the job you do), and corporate social responsibility strategies all appear to be changes that have been adopted. But they have not succeeded in combating the entropy of an industrial economy based on standardization and resource depletion. The systemic dysfunctions encountered presuppose the production not only of anti-entropy (Morlat et al. 2020, p.136), but also of negentropy, i.e.: diversification and movement. In this respect, it's not so much the number of third places that's important - over 3,700 by 2024 - as their diversity: third places for food, third places for culture, third places for crafts, third places for agro-ecology, third places for solidarity, and so on. They all represent a socio-economic movement towards a sustainable development model for the localities where they are created and where they evolve. For Stiegler (2020, p.82): "the locality is the place from which emerges an orientation, i.e. a meaning - an end, arising from a part of an experience shared by a community, thus constituting a knowledge, or rather a bundle of knowledges, always already in the process of diffracting towards a diversely open future".

Third places for societal transition: user-friendly structures!

Illich (1973, p.43) refers to "the other possibility: a user-friendly structure". He explains: "a user-friendly society is one that gives man the possibility of exercising the most autonomous and creative action, using tools that are less controllable by others. Productivity is conjugated in terms of having, conviviality in terms of being". Transitional third places appear to be convivial structures that break with the past, because they serve the men and women who work there, and are controlled by them. Transitional third places thus become potential bifurcation points, moving away from the industrial economy model to raise the societal values of citizens according to economic, social and governance potentialities, linking all living beings at the scale of each territory. Let's not forget that: "transition emerges from local citizen initiatives" (Beucher and Mare 2020, p. 386). Solidarity-based third-places are experimenting with the breakthroughs needed for transition, and truly represent a new, more sustainable model of territorial development!

 


Indicative bibliography:

  • Beucher S., Mare M., 2020, « Cadre épistémologique de la notion de transition en sciences humaines et en géographie », Bulletin de l’Association des Géographes Français [On line], 97-4/2020, p. 382-394, en ligne le 31 juillet 2021, consulté le 31 décembre 2021. URL : http ://journals.openedition.org/bagf/7554.
  • Glémain P., Billaudeau V., 2021, « Les autres lieux de l’entrepreneuriat et du salariat », Revue d’Économie Régionale et Urbaine-RERU, 2021/5 Décembre, p.927-951.
  • Glémain P. ? Billaudeau V., 2022, « Les Tiers-Lieux de Transition Sociétale en Région Ouest de la France : Penser un transitio-mètre pour comprendre leurs effets transitionnels au niveau local ». Norois, 2022/3 n° 264-265, p.139-155.
  • Illich I., 1973, La convivialité. Paris, Éditions du Seuil.
  • Morlat C., Landau O., Sentis Th., Cormerais F., Alombert A., Krzykawski M., 2020, « Économie contributive, processus territoriaux de capacitation et nouvelles modalités comptable », p.127-156, dans Stiegler B. (dir)., 2020, Bifurquer. Paris, Les Liens qui Libèrent-LLL.
  • Stiegler B. (dir)., 2020, Bifurquer. Paris, Les Liens qui Libèrent-LLL

Release date: June 2024

Read more

Offsite will not happen without a profound digital and cultural transformation

Contact - Frédéric Maillet

Frédéric Maillet

Head of Consulting & Project Management

+33 6 71 99 37 78

fmaillet@kardham.com

The effects of teleworking on commuting

Eléonore Pigalle

Eléonore Pigalle

Doctor in Urban Planning and Spatial Planning
Associate researcher at the City Mobility Transport Laboratory at Gustave Eiffel University and the Ecole des Ponts ParisTech